Incentives for Levying Countervailing Duties on Foreign Competitive Goods
Yu-Ter Wang1*
1Department of Economics and Finance, Ming Chuan University, Taiwan Region, China
*Correspondence to: Yu-Ter Wang, PhD, Professor, Department of Economics and Finance, Ming Chuan University, 5 De Ming Rd., Gwei Shan, Taoyuan 333, Taiwan Region, China; E-mail: ytwang@mail.mcu.edu.tw
DOI: 10.53964/mem.2023012
Abstract
Objective: The relationships between firm profits, foreign export subsidy, and countervailing duties (CVDs) have not been discussed sufficiently in the existing related literature. The purpose of the present study is to analyze the effects of CVDs and formulate policy advice regarding CVDs to fill this knowledge gap.
Methods: A game theoretic model with oligopolistic market structure is adopted.
Results: The proposed model indicates that when a foreign country provides an export subsidy to a foreign final good, a domestic country has an incentive to levy a CVD whose value exceeds that of the foreign export subsidy on the foreign final good because domestic intermediate- and final-good firms might benefit from the CVD.
Conclusions: A CVD whose value equals that of a foreign export subsidy is enough to counter the subsidy’s negative effects on the profits made by domestic intermediate- and final-good firms.
Keywords: countervailing duties, export subsidies, oligopoly, vertically related industries
1 INTRODUCTION
The World Trade Organization (WTO) Agreement on Subsidies and Countervailing Measures specifies rules for implementing government subsidies and addressing the negative commercial effects of subsidized trade. One method for addressing the aforementioned negative effects involves a WTO member country unilaterally imposing a countervailing duty (CVD) on specific exports.
Collie[1] presented a case in which the United States levied a CVD of over 100% on subsidized steel imports from the European Union; this case indicates the possibility of CVDs exceeding foreign export subsidies in real-world scenarios. Qiu[2] tried to explain why CVDs cannot stop foreign countries to subsidize their exports by using an oligopoly theoretical model. Marvel and Ray[3] contended that CVDs are often more detrimental than the subsidies that they are aimed at countering. These authors questioned whether CVDs are protectionist measures or measures for reducing trade distortions. Carter et al.[4] indicated that in 1985, rent-seeking activities resulted in the Unites States imposing a CVD on hog imports from Canada. Wang[5] analyzed the relationship between import tariffs, CVDs and foreign export subsidies. Zhu et al.[6] found that CVDs in the United States on imports of coated free-sheet paper from China caused a decline in Chinese printing production; US imports of Chinese paper also decreased. The United States saw increases in producer revenues, consumer expenditures, and value added; however, these increases were marginal relative to those of Canada. Brown[7] found that temporary trade barriers such as CVDs are becoming a South-South phenomenon. Rovegno[8] studied the impact of US CVDs on domestic producers’ price-cost margins and accounted for potential endogeneity in CVDs and the intensity of the protection granted. Kelly[9] explored the subsidy pass-through effect and found that nations generally set CVDs to be equal to the subsidy granted to the exporter. However, they disregarded the potential influence of subsidies on import prices. Chandra[10] studied the impact of the US CVDs on Chinese exports and found that it has raised the exports from China to other countries. Lo[11] argued that the WTO allows members to levy CVDs on subsidized imports that may harm the related domestic industries. Kuang and Xiang[12] indicated that CVDs have a limited remedial effect on the PV industry in the US. They used a computable partial equilibrium model to demonstrate that the US incurred a welfare loss from its CVDs. Nizovtsev and Skiba[13] investigated the pass-through effect of CVDs on US import prices, and their empirical results supported the theory. Frering[14] focused on the US CVDs on ripe olives imported from Spain and analyzed the impact on domestic ripe olives industry by considering factors including volume, price effects and the state of domestic producers.
As we know, there are a lot of papers focused on empirical studies. Only few theoretical studies are presented such as those of Collie[1], Qiu[2], and Wang[5] which examined CVDs and foreign export subsidies in a non-vertically related industry characterized by oligopoly. Moreover, most industries are connected to other industries upstream or downstream because of the nature of the supply chain. Export subsidization is implemented to increase domestic firm profits, whereas CVDs are implemented on subsidized imports to protect domestic firms. Consequently, anti-subsidy accusations typically originate from importing firms in vertically related industries. The relationships between firm profits, foreign export subsidy, and CVDs have not been discussed sufficiently. The purpose of the present study is to analyze the effects of CVDs and formulate policy advice regarding CVDs in a vertical related industry for filling this knowledge gap.
The rest of this paper is structured as follows: Section II describes the method for analysis. Section III presents the results and discussion concerning the relationships between firm profits, foreign export subsidies, and CVDs in a vertically related industry. Finally, Section IV provides the conclusions of this study.
2 METHODS
|
|
Moreover, the profits made by the domestic and foreign intermediate-good firms are expressed as follows:
|
|
A sequential game comprising two decision-making stages for the involved firms will be taken into account. In the first stage, the domestic and foreign intermediate-good firms determine the quantity of intermediate goods to be supplied to the domestic market. In the second stage, these firms consider the price of the intermediate good to determine their optimal levels of final good output. The firms consider the foreign export subsidy and CVD as fixed factors in their decision-making process.
3 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The derivation process is as follows. Given the level for foreign export subsidies and CVDs on the intermediate good and the final good (i.e., σ1, σ2, ρ1 and ρ2), in the second stage the Cournot equilibrium outputs for the domestic and the foreign final-good firms are obtained by maximizing their own profits (i.e., Equations (1) and (2)) respectively:
|
|
Substituting Equations (5) and (6) into the final good’s inverse demand function gives the equilibrium price of the final good:
|
After the outputs for the domestic and the foreign final-good firms have been determined in the second stage, in the first stage the Cournot equilibrium outputs for the domestic and the foreign intermediate-good firms are gotten by maximizing their own profits (i.e., Equations (3) and (4)) respectively:
|
|
The equilibrium condition for the supply and demand quantity being equal in the intermediate-good market yields the equilibrium price of the intermediate good:
|
Here π1(π1*) and Π1(Π1*) denote the profits made by the final- and intermediate-good domestic (foreign) firms, respectively, under the existence of an export subsidy for the foreign intermediate good, foreign final good, or both goods. The following equations are derived from Equations (1)-(10):
|
|
|
|
Substituting ρ2=0 and σ2=0 into Equations (11)-(14) gives the domestic and foreign firms’ profit for intermediate good and final good which are denoted in turn by π2, π*2, Π2, and Π*2, when the foreign government doesn’t subsidize its intermediate good or final good (i.e., ρ1=σ1=0).
By the calculation of Equations (11)-(14) and using the definitions stated above, the main results can be derived as follows:
(1) If σ1=σ2 and ρ1<ρ2, then П2<П1, π2>π1, П*2>П*1, π*2<π*1.
(2) If σ1<σ2 and ρ1=ρ2, then П2<П1, π2<π1, П*2<П*1, π*2<π*1.
(3) If σ1<σ2 and ρ1<ρ2, then П2<П1, π2<or>π1, П*2<or>П*1, π*2<or>π*1.
(4) If σ1=σ2 and ρ1=ρ2, then П2=П1, π2=π1, П*2=П*1, π*2=π*1.
In the above satements, <or> means both “<” and “>” are possible in the case.
Several key findings are entailed from the main results. First, when a domestic government levies an overfull CVD on a foreign intermediate good in response to a foreign export subsidy, the domestic intermediate-good firm exhibits increased profits, whereas the domestic final-good firm exhibits decreased profits. This outcome occurs because of the increased competitiveness and production costs of the domestic intermediate- and final-good firms, respectively. Second, when a domestic government levies an overfull CVD on a foreign final good, the market share and input purchases of the domestic final-good firm increase. Consequently, a foreign export subsidy results in increased profits for the domestic intermediate-good firm, domestic final-good firm, and foreign intermediate-good firm but losses for the foreign final-good firm. Third, when a domestic government levies an overfull CVD on a foreign intermediate good and final good, only the profits of the domestic intermediate-good firm are guaranteed to increase. The profits of the domestic final-good firm, foreign final-good firm, and foreign intermediate-good firm might decrease or increase under the aforementioned scenario. If a CVD exceeding 100% is levied on a foreign intermediate good, the foreign intermediate-good firm might be compelled to exit the domestic market. The levying of a CVD that equals the foreign export subsidy can counteract the effects of this subsidy on the profits of domestic intermediate- and final-good firms. This policy also results in increased profits for the foreign intermediate- and final-good firms, which eliminates the foreign government’s incentive to provide a subsidy for its exports. Consequently, the price and output levels of the intermediate- and final-good firms return to their presubsidy levels.
The aforementioend analysis reveals that a domestic intermediate-good firm consistently benefits when the domestic government levies a CVD with a higher value than that of a foreign export subsidy. Overfull CVDs do not necessarily result in losses for foreign firms. For instance, the levying of an overfull CVD on a foreign final good results in increased profit for the foreign intermediate-good firm. Similarly, the levying of an overfull CVD on a foreign intermediate good results in increased profit for the foreign final-good firm. An overfull CVD must be levied exclusively on the foreign final good to ensure that a foreign export subsidy benefits both the domestic intermediate- and final-good firms.
An incentive exists for a domestic government to impose a CVD on a foreign final good, even if only the exported intermediate good is subsidized by the foreign government. This policy benefits the domestic intermediate- and final-good firms. However, if a foreign export subsidy is applied solely to the final good, the levying of a CVD on the foreign intermediate good results in an increase in the profits of the domestic intermediate-good firm but a decrease in the profits of the domestic final-good firm.
Under a foreign export subsidy for intermediate goods, final goods, or both types of goods, governments must understand how CVDs shoud be employed to protect domestic intermediate- and final-good. Governments should consider whether a CVD that exceeds a foreign export subsidy can benefit domestic firms. In some cases, a foreign government might impose an export subsidy on the intermediate and final goods from a domestic country. In response, the domestic government might levy a CVD solely on the final and intermedate goods from the foreign country.
4 CONCLUSION
This study examined firm profits, foreign export subsidies, and CVDs in vertically related markets under WTO regulations by using a game theoretic model. The key conclusions of this study are as follows. First, if the value of a CVD levied on a foreign final good exceeds that of the foreign export subsidy for this good, the profits of the domestic intermediate- and final-good firms increase. Thus, an incentive exists for a domestic government to levy a CVD on a foreign final good, even in the absence of a subsidy by the foreign government. Second, a CVD whose value equals that of a foreign export subsidy counters the subsidy’s negative effects on the profits made by domestic intermediate- and final-good firms. Finally, under specific circumstances, the levying of a CVD exceeding 100% might benefit subsidized foreign intermediate- and final-good firms.
Acknowledgements
I deeply appreciate the very constructive comments and suggestions from the editors and the anonymous reviewer. However, any remaining errors are my own responsibility.
Conflicts of Interest
The author declared no conflict of interest.
Author Contribution
Wang YT contributed to the manuscript and approved the final version.
Abbreviation List
CVD, Countervailing duty
WTO, World Trade Organization
References
[1] Collie D. Strategic Trade Policy and Retaliation. Jpn World Econ, 1994; 6: 75-88.[DOI]
[2] Qiu LD. Why Can’t Countervailing Duties Deter Export Subsidization? J Int Econ, 1995; 39: 249-272.[DOI]
[3] Marvel HP, Ray EJ. Countervailing Duties. Econ J, 1995; 105: 1576-1593.[DOI]
[4] Carter C, Chadee D, Darko K. Are Subsidies to Be Blamed? A Reexamination of US Countervailing Duty on Hog Imports from Canada. J Policy Model, 1999; 21: 823-830.[DOI]
[5] Wang YT. Countervailing Duties, Foreign Export Subsidies and Import Tariffs. Jpn Econ Rev, 2004; 55: 153-161.[DOI]
[6] Zhu S, Turner JA, Buongiorno J. Long-term Economic Impact of Countervailing Duties on Coated Free Sheet Paper Imported by the United States from China, the Republic of Korea, and Indonesia. Forest Prod J, 2008; 58: 71-77.
[7] Brown CP. Taking Stock of Antidumping, Safeguards and Countervailing Duties, 1990-2009. World Econ, 2011; 34: 1955-1998.[DOI]
[8] Rovegno L. Trade Protection and Market Power: Evidence from US Antidumping and Countervailing duties. Rev World Econ, 2013; 149: 443-476.[DOI]
[9] Kelly BD. The Pass-through of Subsidies to Price. J World Trade, 2014; 48: 295-321.[DOI]
[10] Chandra P. Impact of Temporary Trade Barriers: Evidence from China. China Econ Rev, 2016; 38: 24-48.[DOI]
[11] Lo C. Subsidy Extinction and the Distinction between Company and Shareholders under the SCM Agreement: Proposing a Control-Centered Approach. Asian J Wto Int Heal, 2018; 13: 551-552.
[12] Kuang Y, Xiang H. Who Benefits from Antidumping and Countervailing? An Analysis Using a Computable Partial Equilibrium Model. Emerg Mark Financ Tr, 2019; 55: 409-426.[DOI]
[13] Nizovtsev D, Skiba A. Non‐equivalent Pass‐through of Anti‐dumping Duties, Countervailing Duties and Import Tariffs. World Econ, 2020; 43: 170-190.[DOI]
[14] Frering G. The Olives of Others: The United States’ Anti-Dumping and Countervailing Duties on Ripe Olives from Spain. Am U Int'l L Rev, 2020; 36: 651-696.
Copyright © 2023 The Author(s). This open-access article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, sharing, adaptation, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.




Copyright ©